Gabriele Lamonaca of Unregular Pizza

Unregular Pizza

Pizzeria in NYC Lets Customers Barter for a Pie Once a Day

Gabriele Lamonaca spent last year trading his homemade pizzas for baked goods. Now he's parlayed that success into his own brick-and-mortar shop called Unregular Pizza.

  • The pandemic screwed up Gabriele Lamonaca’s plans to open a pizzeria last year, so he took to Instagram to promote a bartering system for his pies.
  • Now he’s selling pies for cash, but he still makes one barter trade every day at Unregular Pizza.

Related: This Instagram pop-up peddles bootleg pizza to help nonprofits

Aspiring pizzeria owner Gabriele Lamonaca spent much of the pandemic year of 2020 making pizzas in his home kitchen in Harlem and swapping them for other homemade foods in a highly publicized project he called Unregular Pizza. Now his hard work—and shrewd marketing through Instagram—has paid off. He opened his own brick-and-mortar pizza shop, also called Unregular Pizza, in Union Square last week.

As Eater.com reports, Lamonaca partnered up with pizza/pastry chef Salvatore Gagliardo in the new business, which opened on May 18. And while his pizzas now come with a price tag that’s not negotiable, he hasn’t completely abandoned his bartering model.

On May 20, Lamonaca conducted a trade with the first person who bartered for one of his pies last year. And he will continue to conduct trades once a day, signaled by the ringing of a bell, to keep the tradition alive at his shop.

“Extrapolating from an ancient tradition which springs from necessity, this pizzeria will be the first shop in NYC (and possibly the world) to offer one barter a day in exchange for any food or drink creation New Yorkers feel like bartering,” a press release for Unregular Pizza states.

Lamonaca makes a trade with actress Cara Buono outside his home in Harlem.

As PMQ reported in the Moneymakers section of its April issue, Lamonaca had planned to open a pizza shop in the Big Apple last year, but the pandemic scuttled his plans. Instead, he continued to refine his recipes—and develop new ones—at home and announced that he would happily trade them with his friends in exchange for baked goods and other items. When he began posting photos of the trade-offs on his Instagram page, he attracted more followers as well as the attention of the local media, including the New York Post and websites like Time Out and Eater.com.

Before long, he was bartering his pizzas for goodies like homemade pastas, desserts, breads, bottles of wine and tins of sardines. A photographer traded a photo shoot for a pizza, while a dentist paid him with Chinese brandy chicken and a pair of electric toothbrushes.

Lamonaca told the New York Post earlier this year that the trades are always “exciting,” adding, “You never know what you’re going to get in the barter.”

Still, getting paid in chocolate cakes won’t pay the rent. So Unregular Pizza now charges anywhere between $4.50 and $8 for slices and $24 to $39 for whole six-slice trays/pies. Menu items include the Diavolona (all-natural pepperoni, fior di latte mozzarella and housemade hot honey); the Prochute (prosciutto di Parma, mozz, Parmigiano Reggiano DOP, sundried tomato sauce and arugula) and the Parmigiana Plus (fried eggplant, mozz, Parmigiano-Reggiano DOP and Bronte-imported pistachio ricotta). He also offers the Unvegan, featuring a cherry tomato confit, asparagus tips and asparagus cream.