By Tracy Morin

With six Chicago-area locations and nationwide availability in grocers’ frozen aisle, PMQ Pizza Hall of Fame member Home Run Inn (HRI) has persevered since its tavern roots in 1923, an incredible 100-plus years. Now it churns out 23 million frozen pies annually—supported by its brick-and-mortar restaurants—but Nick Perrino, CRO of the Woodridge, Illinois-based company, is still setting his sights on innovation.

Recently, Perrino paired up with Philadelphia-based marketing agency Quench, which focuses on iconic food and beverage brands. Together, they orchestrated a major investment in building the HRI frozen pizza business nationwide by launching the largest television campaign in the brand’s history. The campaign began airing in select markets nationwide in late October to coincide with National Tavern-Style Pizza Day on October 22. And the ads didn’t appear only on TV; the television campaign was also supported by online and connected video, streaming audio, out-of-home and display advertising.

For the ads, Quench wanted to bring Home Run Inn’s “tavern-to-table” story to life and highlight the family-owned brand’s roots. The ads get that point across by featuring award-winning Chicago blues musician Fruteland Jackson, a longtime Chicago resident and real-life fan of Home Run Inn.

“Everybody is fighting for attention in the frozen pizza aisle, but Home Run Inn has something most brands would kill for: a genuinely great product with a real story to back it up,” says Quench CEO Michael Pavone. “Our job was to take that authenticity and make some noise with it. We wanted people who’ve never heard of Home Run Inn to see the work and think, ‘OK, I’ve got to try that pizza.’”

Perrino and Pavone recently sat down with PMQ to talk about the vision, creation and launch of the ads, how tavern-style pizza is gaining momentum nationwide, and why they believe this promotional push will take HRI’s frozen pizza business to the next level.

PMQ: Why was this the right time to make such a significant investment in this type of advertising, and what business objectives do you hope to accomplish?

Perrino: It’s simple for us: We have the confidence and belief that our pizza can be the No. 1 selling pizza in the entire country. We have been the No. 1 selling frozen pizza in Chicago, the biggest pizza category in the country, for the past 20 years. In addition to that, we are starting to see our brand pick up steam across other areas of the country with a minimal marketing investment. That success, along with consumer feedback about how much they love our crust and the simplicity of our ingredients, led us to go all in. We have built an amazing team, and our team is ready to go show the world what we can do!

PMQ: Thinking about bringing the brand’s heritage to life, what was the inspiration behind the campaign—using a “tavern-to-table” concept and featuring Chicago blues musician Fruteland Jackson?

Pavone: We had a pretty incredible story sitting right in front of us. A family-owned Chicago tavern starts making pizza, people love it, and decades later that same pizza is in freezers across America. You can’t make that stuff up. So the tavern-to-table idea came pretty naturally. And if you’re going to tell a Chicago story, you’ve got to bring some Chicago soul to it. That’s where Fruteland Jackson came in. He’s the real deal, a blues musician with deep Chicago roots and a true professional. There’s a grit and authenticity to his music that fits Home Run Inn perfectly. We had a blast working with him and think he had some fun, too.

Perrino: Chicago is a huge part of who we are. It’s where our family started making pizzas back in 1947, and that history is something we’re really proud of. We wanted the campaign to capture that spirit and show people how our pizza went from a neighborhood tavern to family dinner tables across the country. Fruteland Jackson brings that authentic Chicago sound and personality to the commercials. He’s a great fit for the story we’re telling, and we’re excited he’s a part of introducing our pizza to a whole new audience.

PMQ: The campaign includes television, streaming audio, connected video, out-of-home and digital advertising. How are you thinking about reaching today’s pizza consumers across these different channels, and how will you measure the campaign’s effectiveness?

Perrino: People today are discovering brands and making purchasing decisions in a lot of different ways, so we wanted a campaign that could reach consumers across multiple channels. Television gives us an opportunity to introduce Home Run Inn to a broad audience. Streaming, digital, radio and out-of-home help us reinforce that message and stay visible in the markets where we’re growing. As far as effectiveness, we’ll be looking at how the campaign builds brand awareness and drives sales. At the end of the day, that’s what matters most.

Pavone: People aren’t sitting around waiting for a pizza commercial to come on. They’re watching TV, streaming shows, listening to music, scrolling through their phones and going about their day. Our goal is for Home Run Inn to show up in those moments with a message that gets their attention.

PMQ: What do you believe differentiates Home Run Inn, and how are you communicating that distinction to consumers who may be unfamiliar with the brand?

Perrino: What sets Home Run Inn apart is that our pizza was born in our restaurant, not in a lab or test kitchen. It’s extremely difficult to take a restaurant pizza that people love and make it for the masses, but our products are time-tested with 80 years of history behind them.

Another critical factor is consistency. We pride ourselves on making the same recipe that our grandparents brought over from Italy. You have to be able to build trust with consumers, and that takes time. Our consumers have seen, over 80 years, that they can trust that their Home Run Inn experience will be the exact same. We are committed to always delivering a superior product that is all-natural, has no preservatives, and has a simple label that consumers can understand. These are the things that help set us apart.

In our marketing efforts, we are focused on calling out three critical pillars in all of our messaging: all-natural ingredients, restaurant legacy and family-owned. We know who our core consumer is, and we are going 100 miles deep to target them on a consistent basis. Our simple messaging of “It’s Tavern to Table” helps create a memory structure that is easy to understand. Simplicity is key!

PMQ: Are you seeing increased consumer interest in tavern-style pizza in markets outside of the Midwest?

Perrino: We’re definitely seeing more interest in tavern-style pizza beyond Chicago and the Midwest. We know that 78% of frozen pizza consumers outside of Chicago know what tavern-style pizza is. The growing attention comes as thin-crust pizza continues to appeal to consumers nationwide.

According to 2025 research from the American Bakers Association, 49% of consumers prefer thin-crust pizza, suggesting plenty of appetite for Chicago’s crispy, square-cut favorite. For a long time, Chicago pizza was almost synonymous with deep dish, but more people are discovering that the thin, crispy, tavern crust that is cut into squares are what true Chicagoans eat. That’s exciting for us, because tavern-style pizza is what we’ve been making for 80 years. As we expand into new markets, we have a great opportunity to introduce more people to that tradition and give them a taste of authentic Chicago pizza at home.

PMQ: As Home Tun Inn continues expanding its frozen pizza distribution nationally, which markets represent the greatest opportunities for growth?

Perrino: We’re excited about the growth opportunities we’re seeing in markets like Tampa, Orlando and Atlanta, where we’ve already established a presence. Those are key priorities for us right now, along with continuing to build on our strong foundation in Chicago.

PMQ: How are you approaching retail expansion while maintaining the brand’s strong connection to its Chicago heritage?

Perrino: Our Chicago roots are a big part of what makes Home Run Inn special. We’re still a family-owned business making the same tavern-style pizza that we’ve been making for generations. As we enter new markets and reach new consumers, we want to bring that history and tradition with us. That’s really what this campaign is all about. We’re introducing Home Run Inn to more people while staying true to who we are and where we came from.

We always want to give consumers something new and exciting, but we’re also very mindful of what made Home Run Inn successful in the first place. People love our pizza for a reason, and we don’t want to lose sight of that. There’s plenty of room to try new things without losing what makes us special.

PMQ: The company has indicated that additional branding support is expected in early 2027. What can consumers and retail partners expect next, and how do you envision the HRI brand evolving over the next few years?

Perrino: We see a lot of opportunity ahead for Home Run Inn. Over the next three to five years, our focus will be on continuing to grow our frozen pizza business, expanding into new markets and introducing the brand to more consumers across the country. We also continue to innovate and just introduced a pan pizza offering. It retains our commitment to all-natural ingredients and restaurant roots while introducing consumers to something new from a brand they trust.

At the same time, we want to keep building on the loyalty and trust right here in the Chicago area. Chicago is our home, and no matter how much we grow, that’s never going to change.

Tracy Morin is PMQ’s associate editor.

Marketing, Pizzerias