By Tracy Morin
Ray McConn, owner of Mother Bear’s Pizza in Bloomington, Indiana, admits he didn’t have much of a plan when he opened a bar, Bear’s Place, with his friend Bruce Storm in 1971.
“Young and dumb would be an understatement,” McConn says with a laugh. “I always wanted to have a college bar and wanted to serve pizza, but the kitchen wasn’t big enough.”
Now Mother Bear’s has been inducted into PMQ’s Pizza Hall of Fame (PHOF). And one thing’s for sure: It doesn’t feel like a typical old-school PHOF brand. The vibe is young, smartly funny, irreverent and just a little bit silly.
McConn was only 26 when Mother Bear’s opened in 1973, scoring a prime location in a former pizzeria at the edge of Indiana University’s (IU) campus. “The recipe for the first three to five years was a hodgepodge,” McConn says. “Different managers threw in their own styles. Then we got a good guy in there, and he solidified it. It was a hit.”

By 1979, Mother Bear’s was hailed as the best pizza in Bloomington by IU’s student-run newspaper. Then business doubled overnight in 1982, when People magazine named it one of the top nine in America. Today, the original rakes in $5 million annually.
A more spacious second location, with patio seating, opened in 2016 and was soon clearing $100,000 a week. Two years ago, Mother Bear’s ventured to Columbus, Indiana, where its third outpost is still growing.
Mother Bear’s has found success with a something-for-everyone menu, giving back to local causes, and all delivery handled in-house. Every day, the pizzeria sells 200 to 300 Munchie Madness deals—a 10” one-topping pie, breadsticks, two-liter soda and two brownies—while wing nights and drink specials also attract the college crowd.

Still, McConn isn’t afraid to try new things. “Advertising used to be so easy—put an ad in the college paper, and they came,” he says. “Now, we’ve hired a local marketing company, and they’ve done wonders. They create skits in the store [for social media videos—see example below], and it’s made a big difference.
“You also have to keep in touch with the staff, because the attitude of the staff is what helps sell your business,” McConn continues. “You have to be aware of what the business is doing and how it’s doing it. And you have to keep stirring the pot; you never know what’s going to work. It’s amazing, this journey—through a lot of ups and downs, it’s been very gratifying. I feel blessed.”