- Pepperoni is one of the most versatile ingredients in the pizzeria kitchen. You just have to think outside the pizza box.
- Imagine crispy, crumbled pepperoni on top of a creamy potato soup or cubed spicy pepperoni in a cup of homemade minestrone.
Recipe: Cup’n Char Pepperoni and Peppadews Pizza from Smithfield
Acclaimed pizza chef Lee Hunzinger didn’t much care for pepperoni when he was growing up. “I didn’t like how the grease ran all over the pie,” admits Hunzinger, PMQ’s June-July 2016 cover star and former manager and pizzaiolo at Cane Rosso in Fairview, Texas. But pepperoni has changed over the years, with Instagram-worthy cups of meat nirvana, super-spicy disks of fire that cater to a growing heat-loving society, and natural varieties geared toward more health-conscious pizza lovers.
Once Hunzinger discovered cup-and-char pepperoni, he was sold. “It keeps the grease from running all over,” he says. “The flavor is so good, and it crisps up like bacon.”
Today’s vendors offer upwards of 10 to 20 varieties of pepperoni and can custom-create a pepperoni for your pizza. Depending on your style of pizza, you can order a variety that’s natural, mild, spicy, thick- or thin-sliced, or not sliced at all. “Nowadays, when you’re ordering pepperoni from your salesperson, you can choose the thickness of the cut, which I think has a lot to do with the cupping,” Hunzinger notes. “Obviously, the thicker the cuts, the less pepperoni you’ll get, but the cuppage will be better than those that are cut thin.”
And, Hunzinger adds, if cupping is what you’re looking for, size matters. “The small pepperonis cup quicker because it’s a smaller area to create that dimple. It generally starts cupping up after one and a half or two minutes. Sometimes, if I’m putting it on a New York-style pie that’s baking for five minutes, I’ll let some pepperoni cook on there the whole time. Then I’ll fill in the gaps during the last two minutes with more pepperoni so you have some crispier than others.”
With expanding pepperoni varieties, the door is left wide open for creating some fantastic appetizers, salads, sandwiches and more—all using what you already have on hand. As America’s favorite topping, you already know that your guests love pepperoni, so let’s take a look at some other ways you can utilize it in your pizzeria.
Recipe: Crispy Pepperoni and Egg Breakfast Pizza by Margherita
For an upcharge, offer pepperoni as an addition to your appetizers, like potato skins, artichoke dip, breadsticks, nachos, garlic knots or cheese plates. Or create a fun pizza dip using your sauce, pepperoni, ricotta and cream cheese to serve with breadsticks. We’ve also seen large risotto balls stuffed with pepperoni and mozzarella, rolled in breadcrumbs and deep-fried to create pepperoni arancini. At Cane Rosso, Hunzinger liked to add pepperoni to his cheesy garlic bread.
Green salads get a little kick from sliced or cubed pepperoni, as do cold pasta salads, which make great sides or full lunch entrées. At Nima’s Pizza & More in Gassville, Arkansas, owners Rick and Jane Mines offer customers their choice of two meats on the pizzeria’s Chef Salad.
Do you serve soup at your pizzeria? Imagine crispy, crumbled pepperoni on top of a creamy potato soup or cubed spicy pepperoni in a cup of homemade minestrone. Pepperoni lovers won’t argue with the option to enjoy their favorite topping in more places across your menu.
Italian deli sandwiches just aren’t the same without some spicy pepperoni, and a warm stromboli or calzone packed with pepperoni is always a fan favorite. At Nima’s, the Mines stuff heated marinara sauce and pepperoni into a pocket grinder roll, smother it in mozzarella, and bake it to create the Hot Pepperoni Sub.
In addition to its popular crumbled pepperoni on pizzas, Arni’s Restaurant, a popular Midwest chain, offers a Hot Sicilian Stromboli with baked ham, spiced ham, salami, pepperoni, bacon and all the fixings.
Other possibilities: a grown-up grilled cheese with pepperoni, a pizza burger with mozzarella and pepperoni, or even a twist on Mexican fare with a pizza quesadilla.
Take hot pasta dishes to the next level by adding cubed, sliced or crisped pepperoni. What about adding pepperoni to your Spaghetti and Meatballs, Chicken Parmesan, or Mac and Cheese recipes? Also try adding sliced or cubed pepperoni to other hot pasta dishes, such as Chicken Alfredo.
Feeling wildly creative? While some chefs make bacon jam, whips up a pepperoni and soppressata jam, which he uses on pizza. “The Lady Marmalade pizza is a New York white pie topped with mozzarella, ricotta and the pepperoni-soppressata jam,” he says. We’ve had it. Trust us. It’s amazing!
Pepperoni for dessert? We’re not kidding! Try a savory pizza cake or cupcake adorned with mini-pepperonis. The mix of salty and slightly sweet is pretty amazing.
If you’re ready to start experimenting, just take a look at your menu and add pepperoni to something that doesn’t already have it. Feature the dish as a special during one of your slow nights and see what transpires!
Liz Barrett, PMQ’s former editor at large, is the author of Pizza: A Slice of American History. This article has been updated from the original version appearing in the May 2017 issue of PMQ.