The Scary Truth About Online Reviews: Negative Trumps Positive in Readers' Minds

Most reviews don't reflect reality. Here's why we believe them anyway.

A data sample from found that less than 5 percent of reviews of a verified purchase were rated one star, while 59 percent had five stars. So why do people seem to pay more attention to the negative reviews?

According to the New York Times, a 2016 Pew Research Center survey found that 82 percent of American adults say they sometimes or always read online reviews when looking to make purchases. And more than two-thirds of those who regularly read reviews believe they’re “generally accurate.”

And that especially applies to negative reviews. In fact, marketing data shows that “negative reviews in particular dramatically influence our buying behaviors,” the Times reports.

Yelp explains how to handle negative restaurant reviews.

The apparent reason: Since positive reviews greatly outnumber the negative reviews, we tend to pay more attention to the relatively scarce naysayers. “The infrequent nature of negative reviews may help to distinguish them from other reviews,” Dr. Duncan Simester, a marketing professor at M.I.T., told the Times.

Some people may be suspicious of an abundance of five-star reviews, the article also states, due to media reports claiming these positive reviews could be fake.

But a 2016 study found that online reviews don’t necessarily jibe with reality. The study, published in The Journal of Consumer Research, “looked at whether online reviews reflected objective quality as rated by Consumer Reports” and found “very little correlation.”

Video: How 786 Degrees Earned Almost 800 Positive Yelp Reviews

Of course, that’s because reviewers aren’t being objective—they’re stating their personal opinions and reflecting on their own experiences with the product or service. Several factors play into those experiences, research finds, including whether they're traveling with significant others, friends or family or traveling alone or for business. The latter group tend to leave the most negative reviews.

Moreover, reviewers aren’t your average consumers, according to the Times. They are “more likely to buy things in unusual sizes, make returns, be married, have more children, be younger and less wealthy, and have graduate degrees than the average consumer,” according to Simester. They buy four times more products and are 50 percent more likely to shop sales.

“Very few people write reviews,” Simester told the Times. “It’s about 1.5 percent or 15 people out of 1,000. Should we be relying on these people if we’re part of the other 985?”

Why pizzerias can't afford to ignore online reviews.


Edit Module

Tell us what you think at or email.

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Related Articles

This Company is Pioneering New York-Style Pizza in Pakistan

An elaborate supply chain with links to American pizza makers is making authentic NY-style pizza a possibility in Pakistan.

Pizza Inn Rolls Along with New Meatball Supreme

The new specialty pizza will be added to the buffet line.

Money Magazine, Yelp Name Best Pizza Joints in Each State

Rankings are based on number of online reviews and star ratings.

Pennsylvania Boy Celebrates His Birthday with a Pizza Party for Cops

Jeffrey McCarty got to hobknob with cops and the local bomb squad at his ninth birthday bash.

New Board Members Named for Holding Company of Grain Craft and Southeastern Mills

Rhonda Jordan, Steve Dunphy and Rick Strait join the board of directors for G&L Holdings.

Brooklyn Pizza Master Says This West Coast City Has America's Best Pizza

It's a city without its own signature pizza style, and that's a good thing, says Anthony Falco.

Kazoopy's Pizza Gives Away Pies with a Hemp-Based Crust

The Kalamazoo, Michigan shop threw a pizza party with a little help from their friends at My Hemp Solutions.

Philly Chef Kurt Evans Will Give Ex-Offenders a Second Chance at New Pizzeria

When Down North opens around mid-November, it will feature a staff of formerly incarcerated men and women looking for a new start.

How to Make a Pizza That Looks As Good As It Tastes

A few special touches can turn a good dish into a great pizza in the customers’ eyes, says world champion pizzaiolo Mark Cosentino.

7 Hot Tips for a Better Wood-Fired Pizza

Experts explain how to get the perfect bake from your wood-burning oven (with video).
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags