World's Mightiest Superheroes Stand Guard at Pizza Shop in Grand Island, N.Y.

Say Cheese Pizza Co. and Comic Book Cafe form a single cosmic entity.



This Spider-Man statue lurks on the roof of a combination pizzeria/comic book store in Grand Island, New York.

Say Cheese Pizza Co./Comic Book Cafe

An ever-vigilant Spider-Man crouches on the roof. Thor and the Flash stand guard near the video games. A towering Hulk snarls, fists clenched and ready to strike, in a corner.

If you don’t feel safe from super-villainy at the Comic Book Café, you probably deserve to be kidnapped by Magneto.

Located in Grand Island, New York, the store is actually one-half of a cosmic entity known as Say Cheese Pizza Co./Comic Book Cafe—not necessarily the “secret-identity” half, more like Captain Marvel to Rick Jones, with both “personalities” sharing a single mind and…

Oh, never mind the tortured superhero metaphors. It’s a combination pizzeria and comic book store, and we probably should have just said so from the start.

 

From life-sized statues of crime-fighting crusaders to Star Wars toys, memorabilia and rare comics, the Comic Book Café is “beloved” in its neck of the New York woods, according to the Buffalo News. Kids dig it for the obvious reasons, while adults turn out for the pies and local craft brews, including the recently released Krack Noon Island Pale Ale as well as Magic Hat #9 and the Hayburner IPA from Big Ditch Brewing Company.

The themed restaurant also heroically serves its customer base with events like “My Nerdy Valentine,” described as “a Valentine’s Day event for nerdy couples and singles,” visits from the Bud Light Girls, and the Say Cheese Golf Tourney, an all-day affair that includes 18 holes with lunch and beer on the links followed by a dinner buffet and two-hour open bar back at the restaurant.

Founded in 2004 by Kevin Slachciak, Say Cheese/Comic Book Café isn’t the only comics-themed pizza shop in the country—we have reported before on Gotham City Pizza in Ormond Beach, Florida—but it may be the first. (If you know of an older one, email rick@pmq.com with the details.) And, according to a report by Buffalo’s WGRZ, “the food doesn’t disappoint,” thanks to “standard fare with a twist, like unusual wing flavors from spicy Parmesan to peanut butter and jelly” as well as the Cajun-spiced hot fries.

Edit Module

Tell us what you think at or email.

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Related Articles

This Company is Pioneering New York-Style Pizza in Pakistan

An elaborate supply chain with links to American pizza makers is making authentic NY-style pizza a possibility in Pakistan.

Pizza Inn Rolls Along with New Meatball Supreme

The new specialty pizza will be added to the buffet line.

Money Magazine, Yelp Name Best Pizza Joints in Each State

Rankings are based on number of online reviews and star ratings.

Pennsylvania Boy Celebrates His Birthday with a Pizza Party for Cops

Jeffrey McCarty got to hobknob with cops and the local bomb squad at his ninth birthday bash.

New Board Members Named for Holding Company of Grain Craft and Southeastern Mills

Rhonda Jordan, Steve Dunphy and Rick Strait join the board of directors for G&L Holdings.

Brooklyn Pizza Master Says This West Coast City Has America's Best Pizza

It's a city without its own signature pizza style, and that's a good thing, says Anthony Falco.

Kazoopy's Pizza Gives Away Pies with a Hemp-Based Crust

The Kalamazoo, Michigan shop threw a pizza party with a little help from their friends at My Hemp Solutions.

Philly Chef Kurt Evans Will Give Ex-Offenders a Second Chance at New Pizzeria

When Down North opens around mid-November, it will feature a staff of formerly incarcerated men and women looking for a new start.

How to Make a Pizza That Looks As Good As It Tastes

A few special touches can turn a good dish into a great pizza in the customers’ eyes, says world champion pizzaiolo Mark Cosentino.

7 Hot Tips for a Better Wood-Fired Pizza

Experts explain how to get the perfect bake from your wood-burning oven (with video).
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags