4 Reasons to Use Direct-Mail Marketing for Your Pizzeria

Don't believe the hype about digital marketing - the majority of Americans still prefer something they can hold in their hands.

Jam-packed mailboxes are a thing of the past. Now it's email inboxes that are filled with junk.

Writing letters is practically a dead art, but Americans still make that trek to the edge of the driveway every day, hoping something good has come in the mail. Many even look forward to it. And that means there's still a guaranteed readership for your direct-mail marketing piece.

Like Mark Twain’s rumored passing, the death of direct mail has been greatly exaggerated. “The introduction of social media has helped many pizzeria operators reduce their marketing budgets,” Liz Barrett wrote in the May 2015 issue of PMQ. “However, while you’re spending hours hunched over a computer trying to figure out the best way to get 100 customers to ‘like’ you, the guy down the street just mailed 10,000 direct-mail pieces emblazoned with an irresistible offer to your customers. Which strategy sounds more effective to you?”

Additional reading: Tactics for direct-mail marketing success

Digital marketing has its place, especially since it's cheap, but successful pizzeria marketers use every available tool to the fullest. Here are four reasons why direct-mail marketing still works for pizza restaurant owners:

1. Jam-packed mailboxes are a thing of the past. Nowadays it's your email inbox that's stuffed with junk you'll never read. “Mailboxes are becoming emptier, but people still check them every day,” Alyson Lex of Baltimore-based Rock Your Marketing told Barrett. “You don’t have to speak as loudly to be heard in a place where there isn’t as much competition.”

2. Direct-mail expands your marketing reach. Using direct mail, an operator can saturate an entire neighborhood in a specified ZIP code with coupons and special offers or specifically target new movers in their community. Since most people still check their snail-mail daily, your message is almost guaranteed to at least be seen, if not read, by everyone in that ZIP code. On the other hand, a targeted social media ad, although much cheaper, only reaches those who use that platform regularly.

Additional reading: How to increase pizza sales with door hanger marketing

3. Direct mail has a bigger impact. A 2015 study by Temple University, commissioned by the U.S. Postal Service, found that people processed digital ads quicker but spent more time with physical ads, such as flyers, coupons and other direct-mail pieces. “When viewing physical ads, participants had a stronger emotional response and remembered them better,” the study notes.

4. Customers actually like direct mail better than digital. Seventy-three percent of U.S. consumers said they “prefer direct mail for brand communications because they can read the information at their convenience," a​ccording to a 2013 study by Epsilon. The study also found that 59 percent of respondents agreed with the statement, “I enjoy getting postal mail from brands about new products.” And a surprising 62 percent said they enjoy checking their mailboxes for snail-mail. So start planning a direct-mail marketing campaign for your pizzeria now, and give those folks something to smile about!

Additional reading: Ideas for a More Effective Pizza Box Topper

Edit Module

Tell us what you think at or email.

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Related Articles

Why Buffalo-Style Should Be at the Top of Every Pizza Nerd's Bucket List

Daily Meal's Arthur Bovino says Buffalo-style pizza has "a Detroit amount of cheese ... and a New York City soul."

Robot Waiter at Korean Pizza Hut Could Lead to Revolution in Food Delivery

Robotic delivery could drive down costs for consumers and eliminate need for humans altogether

Pizza Recipe: It's Hard to Top the Popper

This signature pie from the Greathouse of Pizza features fresh jalapenos, bacon and cream cheese

Papa John's Cuts Franchisees Royalties As Sales Keep Going Down

Meanwhile, Ball State University has decided to remove founder John Schnatter's name from two programs

Stefano Casati Brings Roman-Style Pinsas to Chicago

The pinsas at Casati's Pizza Vino are made with imported rice, wheat and soy flours

Why the Pizza Industry is Driving Innovation

The pizza world's adoption of cutting-edge technology has been key to its success.

How to Make the Most of Your Restaurant Data

As data becomes ingrained into everything we do, it’s important to make data-driven decisions so you can run a smarter restaurant.

Add an Authentic Italian Pizza to Your Menu with Pizza Fellas Par-Baked Pizza Crusts and Flatbreads

Par-baked crusts save on labor and equipment costs.

This is The Most Loved Pizza in Trinidad and Tobago

This Caribbean pizza chain made cheddar and pineapple pizza a staple.

BBQ Meets Mac & Cheese in One Amazing Pizza

It's the latest Craft Series menu offering from fast-casual pioneer Your Pie
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags