Papa John’s Warns Gluten-Free Customers: Don’t Try Our Gluten-Free Pizza

One advocate for people with celiac disease said the company wants to cash in on the “gluten-free craze in an inauthentic way.”

Making a gluten-free pizza that’s truly safe for gluten-intolerant consumers has proven a challenge for all pizzerias, but especially for the Big 3 chains.


Papa John’s has warned people with celiac disease not to try its new gluten-free pizza, inspiring a flurry of negative stories in the national media.

The gluten-free crust, which took two years to develop, is made with sorghum, teff, amaranth and quinoa in a gluten-free dedicated facility. But Papa John’s doesn’t recommend that diners with celiac disease or a serious gluten intolerance order the pizza because it may become contaminated with gluten-containing products once it reaches restaurant kitchens.


Experts share 7 tips for creating a safe, enjoyable dining experience for gluten-free customers.


“Operationally, Papa John’s employs procedures to prevent contact with gluten,” the company said in a statement to the press. “And while the crust is prepared in a separate gluten-free facility before being shipped to stores, it is possible that a pizza with gluten-free crust could be exposed to gluten during the in-store, pizza-making process. Therefore, the brand does not recommend its Gluten-Free Crust made with Ancient Grains for customers with celiac disease or serious gluten intolerances.”

Domino’s warns people with celiac disease against trying its gluten-free pizzas for the same reason. “It wouldn’t be entirely honest to guarantee that pizzas made with this crust are absolutely gluten-free,” the company states on its website.


Try this recipe for Fresh Prosciutto Gluten-Free Pizza from DeIorio Foods.


Pizza Hut, on the other hand, partnered with the Gluten Intolerance Group to create a certified gluten-free pizza and does not warn those with celiac disease against eating it. As Entrepreneur reported in 2015, Pizza Hut’s gluten-free ingredients are kept in designated gluten-free kits, and employees are required to prepare the pizzas with gloves, bake them on parchment paper and use a designated gluten-free pizza slicer. But the company still admits that its restaurant kitchens aren’t gluten-free environments and doesn’t guarantee that “any menu item will be completely free of gluten.”

Marilyn Geller, CEO of the Celiac Disease Foundation, said Papa John’s customers should heed the warnings about its gluten-free pies. “I would believe them, and I wouldn’t eat it,” she told USA Today. “Really, people have to go to the pizza parlor website. They have to speak to the manager. They have to advocate for themselves.”

Nikki Ostrower of NAO Nutrition said Papa John’s was sending a mixed message to its customers. “If Papa John’s has a gluten-free crust but is suggesting that folks who have celiac or gluten intolerance stay away from it, then it’s very confusing,” Ostrower told CNBC. “Anytime a company advertises that a product is gluten-free, then anyone who has celiac or gluten intolerance should be able to enjoy it. It sounds like Papa John’s is trying to get in on the gluten-free craze in an inauthentic way.”

Then, again, is there really an authentic way to cash in on a food craze?


Edit Module

Tell us what you think at or email.

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Related Articles

Beer for Life and German Pizza

New Brewtorium in Austin, Texas, sells German pizza and a beer-for-life program.

Have You Heard of Beach Pizza?

This square pizza started near the shore in the 1940s.

New York Water From Your Tap?

NJ company promises new filtration system will deliver New York-quality water to any city's tap.

How 786 Degrees Has Almost 800 Positive Yelp Reviews

Ali Haider, owner of 786 Degrees in Los Angeles, talks with Bruce Irving about his passion for pizza and igniting that passion in others.

Chocolate Pizza Dough is Now a Thing

This pizzeria puts chocolate inside its pizza dough, and it's incredible!

New Study Says Pizza Stimulates Productivity

Promises of pizza are a bigger motivator than cash, according to study.

Reese and Mindy Make Everyone Want Pizza

Pizza orders surely went up after Reese Witherspoon posted this photo of her and Mindy Kaling eating pizza on the set of A Wrinkle in Time.

Uproar in Milan Over Healthy Pizza

Michelin-starred chef is making enemies with his whole-grain pizza.

How to Make Wild Game Pizza

Field and Stream's editor-in-chief shares his recipe for venison sausage pizza made in a cast iron skillet.

Pi Day Deals

Are you running a Pi Day deal on 3.14?
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags